Any Preference Of Certain Songs?

[Teh Dingo]

I've never been to a concert, so I'd be interested to hear the concert goers opinion on this:



Are there live versions that you feel are better than the studio versions?



I've obviously only seen the live video, but judging from that, I say that I much prefer the live version to "My Baby's in Love With Eddie Vedder" over the album version.



On the flip side, I don't care for the live "Jerry Springer". It's too slowed down, and I know that's so Al can keep up (And it makes you realize why he never even attempted to do "Hardware Store")

[mewrio]

QUOTE I've never been to a concert,

:nervous:



I prefer the concert version of DED, simply because the synthesising effects are more echo-ey and louder. In fact, seeing as all of them were performed at super-high volumes in Brisbane, I prefer all of them to the studio versions.



As for JS, I was in too much of an Al-induced haze to notice.



And Free Delivery is better in concert.

[stupidsurgeon27]

The concert version of WBUL is better than the studio version because it seems to be more a visual thing. Yeah.



-CindyBob

[Moose]

I think the studio versions sound better, but the overall experience of the live concert is much more fun.

[Bruce the Duck]

I much prefer the concert versions of "One More Minute," "Fat," "Like A Surgeon," and "Melanie." And that's not because of the visuals! I think they sound a lot better than the album versions, which isn't to say that the album versions are not good on their own!



I also prefer the beginning of "Bedrock Anthem" in the concert. If you listen to the opening of the album version compared to the opening of "Under the Bridge," Jim's guitar work is really inferior to that of the Chilli Pepper's guitarist (not Flea, but I can't think of his name). But in the concert version of BE, Jim nailed the original intro beautifully.



I also really liked TBBOTIM and MBILWEV live. I have a tape that I recorded from the live DVD. I really like listening to it, independent of the visuals. Sometimes I wish that Al would release a live album inbetween each of his regular albums like Aerosmith does, but then we'd have to wait like 8 years for a new album!

[sarley27]

I think "Eat It" Live is the best guitar work I have ever heard by Jim PERIOD.

So yes, I prefer that version.

Al Gals, stop screaming at Al so I can hear Jim then! He freaking shreds the guitar!!!!!!!

[Bruce the Duck]

I love the whole section of "Fat" after Al leaves the stage, when the band is left to rock out for a couple solid minutes! That's some of the best music the band plays during the whole show!

[Orthography Enthusiast]

I prefer the WAY Live version (Truth or Dare) of LAS over the album version. The music is more interesting, to say nothing of the visuals. :biggrin:



And WBUL is so much better in concert...

[squishsquashgirl]

The studio versions are perfect, without a single flaw, but seeing it live has these advantages:



1. The music is being blasted from a precision sound system through many gigantic speakers.



2. Al is right there on stage. RIGHT THERE! IN FRONT OF YOU!



3. The costumes, lights, and fog really contribute.



4. Perhaps because it is possible for Al to mess up on stage, it is even more fabulous when he gets through a whole show without a single mistake.



5. Even if something does get messed up, you are so overwhelmed by the magic of it all to notice. Al could fall right off the stage, and you would just be in a daze, thinking "Wow, he sure is talented at falling off the stage. Even I can't do that as good as him. He is so multi-talented!"

[Teh Dingo]

QUOTE I think \"Eat It\" Live is the best guitar work I have ever heard by Jim PERIOD.







I was watching WAY Live today and I was thinking the exact same thing. What an underrated guitarist!!!