IMHO review
Posted: Wed May 21, 2003 10:53 pm
Well...I'd have to say that I will always eagerly anticipate a Weird Al-bum, but my enthusiasm may be in danger of waning. I don't remember an Al-bum where I absolutely can't stand 2 songs.
COUCH POTATO - Like a lot of you, I listened to this song, a lot before the Al-bum came out. It still clicks but the whole no video thing is kinda turning me off to this song. Plus take off 1 point for no Buffy reference. 6.5/10
HARDWARE STORE - When I first heard this song, it felt like I was anticipating a roller coaster ride. I was greatly rewarded by the lyrical content of this song. Only Al could make "I'm going to the hardware store." a 35-word segment of the song. And the rapid verse...OMG...it felt like I was headed for terminal velocity there...it just kept going and going. 10/10
TRASH DAY - I'm a mild Nelly fan, but after hearing "Hot in Herre" 27,000 times last summer, the song became a bane for me. Unfortunately, Al's parody didn't save it for me. It starts off mispronouncing Rotten which should have been ROTT-EN not ROTN to make the parody work for me. Although lyrically clever and I somewhat identify with the song (don't ask), it's barely above fingernails on a chalkboard for me. 2/10
PARTY AT THE LEPER COLONY - I tried to get into this song but it just went off as corny to me. It may still have a chance to grow on me, but it just isn't clicking for me. 4/10
ANGRY WHITE BOY POLKA - I happened to have every original song downloaded already when I saw the tracklist so I knew all the songs. Quick point: Al seems to be spending a little longer than normal on each song. The genius of his medleys has been his rapid fire shifting gears. More than once I find myself bogged down in a song before the next one starts. System of a Down and Disturbed were highlights (ooh, and Rage)... 7/10
WANNA B UR LOVR - Maybe it's because he's not a virgin anymore and married that he's getting a little more risque. *wink* I agree the whole torpedo, burrito, etc. was a little more blue than I want my AL. This song has its moments but I just can't sit through it all without hitting the next track button. 1.5/10
A COMPLICATED SONG - Ok, now, I disagree with everyone saying Al is above potty humor. I thought about the Constipated parody since I first heard that song. Although, who else agrees with me that eating lots of pizza would make you have diarrhea, not constipation, but it still works. The marrying his cousin thing was kewl, and a possible reference to that movie a year or two ago - can't think of the name but I think Chris Klein was in it. The decapitated one was cool. Too bad it's really impossible to stand up on any roller coaster made after the 1960s. Still funny though. Being a huge Avril fan helps boost this song for me, the second funniest parody on the album. 8.5/10
WHY DOES THIS ALWAYS HAPPEN TO ME? - I am a huge fan of Ben Folds and this really sounded like a Ben Folds Five song in parts. Ben Folds/Weird Al collaboration = genius. Ben rocks. Al rocks. The song works as the second best song on the album. 9.5/10
ODE TO A SUPERHERO - I tried to get into this song. I tried. I really did. It really does sound like a lame attempt at Saga Begins redux. It has its moments though. It still is better than Trash Day and has some mild replay value and I can sit through it. 5/10
BOB - What did it for me on this song is how well Al hit the Dylan style parody. The palindrome thing was genius really, but was second to his style parody. It's enough to tie for third best song on the album for me. 9/10
E-BAY - Excellent. A good parody of a bad song. It works here, and plus this song lent itself to parody almost as much as Complicated. 9/10
GENIUS IN FRANCE - The Frank Zappa parody was lost on me. Also, I really wouldn't hold it against Al if he did create this parody as a slap to France's recent publicity. The song has a chuckle here and there, but is in no way repeats the success of Albuquerque. 6/10
MY ORDER OF PREFERENCE OF AL-BUMS.
OFF THE DEEP END
BAD HAIR DAY
ALAPALOOZA
RUNNING WITH SCISSORS
EVEN WORSE
POODLE HAT
ANY ALBUM PRE-OFF THE DEEP END
I agree that Poodle Hat was a bit too list-y for my tastes. But it's still good to have new Weird Al, and Hardware Store ranks in my top 5, maybe top 3 Al songs ever.
Mike
COUCH POTATO - Like a lot of you, I listened to this song, a lot before the Al-bum came out. It still clicks but the whole no video thing is kinda turning me off to this song. Plus take off 1 point for no Buffy reference. 6.5/10
HARDWARE STORE - When I first heard this song, it felt like I was anticipating a roller coaster ride. I was greatly rewarded by the lyrical content of this song. Only Al could make "I'm going to the hardware store." a 35-word segment of the song. And the rapid verse...OMG...it felt like I was headed for terminal velocity there...it just kept going and going. 10/10
TRASH DAY - I'm a mild Nelly fan, but after hearing "Hot in Herre" 27,000 times last summer, the song became a bane for me. Unfortunately, Al's parody didn't save it for me. It starts off mispronouncing Rotten which should have been ROTT-EN not ROTN to make the parody work for me. Although lyrically clever and I somewhat identify with the song (don't ask), it's barely above fingernails on a chalkboard for me. 2/10
PARTY AT THE LEPER COLONY - I tried to get into this song but it just went off as corny to me. It may still have a chance to grow on me, but it just isn't clicking for me. 4/10
ANGRY WHITE BOY POLKA - I happened to have every original song downloaded already when I saw the tracklist so I knew all the songs. Quick point: Al seems to be spending a little longer than normal on each song. The genius of his medleys has been his rapid fire shifting gears. More than once I find myself bogged down in a song before the next one starts. System of a Down and Disturbed were highlights (ooh, and Rage)... 7/10
WANNA B UR LOVR - Maybe it's because he's not a virgin anymore and married that he's getting a little more risque. *wink* I agree the whole torpedo, burrito, etc. was a little more blue than I want my AL. This song has its moments but I just can't sit through it all without hitting the next track button. 1.5/10
A COMPLICATED SONG - Ok, now, I disagree with everyone saying Al is above potty humor. I thought about the Constipated parody since I first heard that song. Although, who else agrees with me that eating lots of pizza would make you have diarrhea, not constipation, but it still works. The marrying his cousin thing was kewl, and a possible reference to that movie a year or two ago - can't think of the name but I think Chris Klein was in it. The decapitated one was cool. Too bad it's really impossible to stand up on any roller coaster made after the 1960s. Still funny though. Being a huge Avril fan helps boost this song for me, the second funniest parody on the album. 8.5/10
WHY DOES THIS ALWAYS HAPPEN TO ME? - I am a huge fan of Ben Folds and this really sounded like a Ben Folds Five song in parts. Ben Folds/Weird Al collaboration = genius. Ben rocks. Al rocks. The song works as the second best song on the album. 9.5/10
ODE TO A SUPERHERO - I tried to get into this song. I tried. I really did. It really does sound like a lame attempt at Saga Begins redux. It has its moments though. It still is better than Trash Day and has some mild replay value and I can sit through it. 5/10
BOB - What did it for me on this song is how well Al hit the Dylan style parody. The palindrome thing was genius really, but was second to his style parody. It's enough to tie for third best song on the album for me. 9/10
E-BAY - Excellent. A good parody of a bad song. It works here, and plus this song lent itself to parody almost as much as Complicated. 9/10
GENIUS IN FRANCE - The Frank Zappa parody was lost on me. Also, I really wouldn't hold it against Al if he did create this parody as a slap to France's recent publicity. The song has a chuckle here and there, but is in no way repeats the success of Albuquerque. 6/10
MY ORDER OF PREFERENCE OF AL-BUMS.
OFF THE DEEP END
BAD HAIR DAY
ALAPALOOZA
RUNNING WITH SCISSORS
EVEN WORSE
POODLE HAT
ANY ALBUM PRE-OFF THE DEEP END
I agree that Poodle Hat was a bit too list-y for my tastes. But it's still good to have new Weird Al, and Hardware Store ranks in my top 5, maybe top 3 Al songs ever.
Mike