Limecat @ Aug 31 2008, 02:01 PM wrote:
Why are there two Best Topic categories?
Fixed. The stupid list copied twice when I made it.
ETA: I searched for "Drooling Over Stephen" and couldn't find it, which (I would assume), makes it inelegable.
...also, I have sent uwvark a PM reguarding his requested closing of Weird Al 3 Word. I will make my decision about that once/if I get a reply from him.
JEDM @ Aug 31 2008, 01:52 PM wrote:
Let's say that a catagory has 3 nominees, but only one is blue and the other two are red. What should we do? Is it fair to let the only blue nominee win by default when it had competition? I think the only fair thing to do is to put all three nominees from said topic on the ballot since it wouldn't be fair to just choose one.
I think that if there are any red nominees at the end of the nomination period, then whoever nominated them should be given a chance to explain why they chose them and a certain period of time should be given to see if anyone seconds them.
Wishing you a Twisted Christmas and a Twisted New Year!
Keir @ Aug 31 2008, 08:11 PM wrote:
I think that if there are any red nominees at the end of the nomination period, then whoever nominated them should be given a chance to explain why they chose them and a certain period of time should be given to see if anyone seconds them.
That's a very good idea, Keir. What should the time be? One week? Five days?
Awards: - Most Dedicated Non-Spoiler (2007) - Best GC Thread (2010) - Best TTR Skit (2010) - Outstanding Achievement In Fan Parody (Recorded), Shared With The Rest Of The Minor Celebrities (2015)
JEDM @ Aug 31 2008, 11:52 AM wrote:
I think this is a good example of what BS asked:
Let's say that a catagory has 3 nominees, but only one is blue and the other two are red. What should we do? Is it fair to let the only blue nominee win by default when it had competition? I think the only fair thing to do is to put all three nominees from said topic on the ballot since it wouldn't be fair to just choose one.
I hope that answers your question, BS.
I meant more along the lines of if there just aren't many nominations for a category (like just one or two). I wasn't really take seconding into account.
Big Spoon @ Sep 1 2008, 01:30 AM wrote:
I meant more along the lines of if there just aren't many nominations for a category (like just one or two). I wasn't really take seconding into account.
If there was only one nominee for a catagory, then presumably they would win by default. If there are 2 solid nominees for a catgory reguardless of color, then they would move on to the final ballot.
3 Word was locked because it lost its luster and it lost its creativity. People were using it to spam. It was no longer fun and it was making me sick. Feel free to un-nominate it or whatever.
