Let's say I believeTMBJon wrote:I mean, I deliberately made one mistake to see if you'd catch...
Word Crimes
Moderator: Moderators
- mellow weasel
- Obsessed
- Posts: 2088
- Joined: Wed Jul 02, 2014 1:22 pm
- Location: Lithuania (Europe)
Re: Word Crimes
-
- Regular
- Posts: 232
- Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2014 7:43 am
- Location: Washington
Re: Word Crimes
I let my participles dangle.
Currently serving one year in grammar school for word crimes
- Sailor-Polka-Moon
- Addicted
- Posts: 642
- Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 6:20 am
- Awards: Outstanding Achievement in Fan Artistry - Traditional (2015)
Re: Word Crimes
I LITERALLY COULDN'T GET OUT OF BED.
Ai to warai no! SAILOR POLKA ☆ MOON!
Tsuki ni kawatte-- tanoshi mazettangeru!
8*11*15 - first concert ever ~ ♡ mandatory world tour 2015 ♡
6*9*16 - second time around ~ ♡ ♡ mandatory world tour 2016 ♡ ♡
Tsuki ni kawatte-- tanoshi mazettangeru!
8*11*15 - first concert ever ~ ♡ mandatory world tour 2015 ♡
6*9*16 - second time around ~ ♡ ♡ mandatory world tour 2016 ♡ ♡
- mellow weasel
- Obsessed
- Posts: 2088
- Joined: Wed Jul 02, 2014 1:22 pm
- Location: Lithuania (Europe)
Re: Word Crimes
What happened?Sailor-Polka-Moon wrote:I LITERALLY COULDN'T GET OUT OF BED.
-
- Regular
- Posts: 232
- Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2014 7:43 am
- Location: Washington
Re: Word Crimes
Either there is a massive animal on top of you or last night was very interesting.mellow weasel wrote:What happened?Sailor-Polka-Moon wrote:I LITERALLY COULDN'T GET OUT OF BED.
Currently serving one year in grammar school for word crimes
- algonacchick
- Thanks, Patti!
- Posts: 53948
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2001 2:00 am
- Location: ALgonac, MI
- Contact:
Re: Word Crimes
I know, I shouldn't get into debates with youtubers, but this person is trying to say that it is okay to say _to who_. When is that ever correct?
He used a sentence twice in his post, but changed it the second time, claiming that either way it is correct. What do you think?
Give this to whoever needs it. vs Give this to who needs it.
Don't you have to have a subject between to and who in the second sentence?
I know, it's 1:30 am, but I'm reminded of a meme Jon posted. Something like:
"Come to bed, honey."
"No, someone is being wrong on the internet."
He used a sentence twice in his post, but changed it the second time, claiming that either way it is correct. What do you think?
Give this to whoever needs it. vs Give this to who needs it.
Don't you have to have a subject between to and who in the second sentence?
I know, it's 1:30 am, but I'm reminded of a meme Jon posted. Something like:
"Come to bed, honey."
"No, someone is being wrong on the internet."
4 words that Al said to me that blew me away:
"How's Problem Child doing?" - 7/12/11
So awesome!
Al Team #325
"How's Problem Child doing?" - 7/12/11
So awesome!
Al Team #325
- TMBJon
- Deliriously Dedicated
- Posts: 20491
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 4:24 pm
- Awards: Greatest Member of All Time
- Location: Santa Monica, CA
Re: Word Crimes
I think the only way to resolve this question is to have Skippy and The Sporkman hash it out over the next 27 pages of this thread.algonacchick wrote:I know, I shouldn't get into debates with youtubers, but this person is trying to say that it is okay to say _to who_. When is that ever correct?
He used a sentence twice in his post, but changed it the second time, claiming that either way it is correct. What do you think?
Give this to whoever needs it. vs Give this to who needs it.
Don't you have to have a subject between to and who in the second sentence?
I couldn't tell a dirt clod from a plate of caviar.
- algonacchick
- Thanks, Patti!
- Posts: 53948
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2001 2:00 am
- Location: ALgonac, MI
- Contact:
Re: Word Crimes
Well, this guy answered my post, and explained why he was right. I still think he's not, and we shall see. I posted the question on a grammar website. So far, my comment is awaiting moderation. Update: I found an example of exactly what I was talking about, without having to wait for an answer. I don't like the way this guy replied to me. The explanation was okay, but he added. "I am correct. Thanks for playing." He has done that to a few other people. Just seems cocky. Anyway, it's not earth-shattering stuff, I just want to find out which is correct.
Here is the example I found:
“Give it to who/whom?” is a sentence of one clause and is a different sentence from “Give it to whoever/whomever asks for it first,” a sentence of two clauses where you must consider each clause before deciding whether to use whoever or whomever. Since you cannot substitute him in both clauses (Give it to him. He asks for it first.) The correct sentence is “Give it to whoever asks for it first.”
His sentence has two clauses as well, and can be broken down:
Give this to him. He needs it. So, "Give this to whoever needs it." is correct. I can sleep at night now.
Well, now I've been proven wrong. I checked his sentence on about 5-6 grammar checkers, and they all said there were no errors. I always thought there had to be a subject between to and who. Live and learn.
Here is the example I found:
“Give it to who/whom?” is a sentence of one clause and is a different sentence from “Give it to whoever/whomever asks for it first,” a sentence of two clauses where you must consider each clause before deciding whether to use whoever or whomever. Since you cannot substitute him in both clauses (Give it to him. He asks for it first.) The correct sentence is “Give it to whoever asks for it first.”
His sentence has two clauses as well, and can be broken down:
Give this to him. He needs it. So, "Give this to whoever needs it." is correct. I can sleep at night now.
Well, now I've been proven wrong. I checked his sentence on about 5-6 grammar checkers, and they all said there were no errors. I always thought there had to be a subject between to and who. Live and learn.
4 words that Al said to me that blew me away:
"How's Problem Child doing?" - 7/12/11
So awesome!
Al Team #325
"How's Problem Child doing?" - 7/12/11
So awesome!
Al Team #325
-
- Addicted
- Posts: 910
- Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2003 8:29 pm
- Location: Lincoln, Nebraska
Re: Word Crimes
"Whoever" is the subject of the relative clause. You're expecting the preposition "to" to take an object functioning as the antecedent of the relative pronoun. However, indefinite relative pronouns like "whoever" and "whichever" often do not have antecedents; rather, the entire relative clause itself functions as a nominal phrase in the main clause and, in this case, as the object of the preposition. Whether or not "who" can function the same way as "whoever" is probably something that varies by dialect.
Does that help?
Does that help?
- algonacchick
- Thanks, Patti!
- Posts: 53948
- Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2001 2:00 am
- Location: ALgonac, MI
- Contact:
Re: Word Crimes
I don't know. This person was challenging Al's lyrics by proving you can say to who as well as to whom. It just sounds wrong.
I thanked him for the healthy discussion after posting about how I discovered he was right after all. I wanted to be the classy one.
I thanked him for the healthy discussion after posting about how I discovered he was right after all. I wanted to be the classy one.
4 words that Al said to me that blew me away:
"How's Problem Child doing?" - 7/12/11
So awesome!
Al Team #325
"How's Problem Child doing?" - 7/12/11
So awesome!
Al Team #325